I have a project where I need to analyze a text to extract some information if the user who post this text need help in something or not, I tried to use sentiment analysis but it didn't work as expected, my idea was to get the negative post and extract the main words in the post and suggest to him some articles about that subject, if there is another way that can help me please post it below and thanks.
for the dataset i useed, it was a dataset for sentiment analyze, but now I found that it's not working and I need a dataset use for this subject.
Please use the NLP methods before processing the sentiment analysis. Use the TFIDF, Word2Vector to create vectors on the given dataset. And them try the sentiment analysis. You may also need glove vector for the conducting analysis.
For this topic I found that this field in machine learning is called "Natural Language Questions" it's a field where machine learning models trained to detect questions in text and suggesting answer for them based on data set you are working with, check this article for more detail.
Related
I am beginner to Machine Learning and NLP, I have to create a bot based on FAQ dataset, Each FAQ dataset excel file contains 2 columns "Questions" and its "Answers".
Eg. A record from an excel file (A question & it's answer).
Question - What is RASA-NLU?
Answer - Rasa NLU is trained to identify intent and entities. Better the training, better the identification...
We have 3K+ excel files which has around 10K to 20K such records each excel.
To implement the bot, I would have followed exactly this FAQ bot approach which uses RASA-NLU, but the RASA,Chatterbot also Microsoft's QnA maker are not allowed in my organization.
And Spacy does the NER extraction perfectly for me, so I am looking for a bot creation using Spacy. but I don't know how to proceed further after extracting the entities. (IMHO, I will have to predict the exact question from dataset (and its answer from knowlwdge base) from user query to the bot)
I don't know what NLP algorithm/ ML process to be used or is there any easiest way to create that FAQ bot using extracted NERs.
One way to achieve your FAQ bot is to transform the problem into a classification problem. You have questions and the answers can be the "labels". I suppose that you always have multiple training questions which map to the same answer. You can encode each answer in order to get smaller labels (for instance, you can map the text of the answer to an id).
Then, you can use your training data (the questions) and your labels (the encoded answers) and feed a classifier. After the training your classifier can predict the label of unseen questions.
Of course, this is a supervised approach, so you will need to extract features from your training sentences (the questions). In this case, you can use as a feature the bag-of-word representations and even include the named entities.
An example of how to do text classification in spacy is available here: https://www.dataquest.io/blog/tutorial-text-classification-in-python-using-spacy/
I'm using OpenNLP for data classification. I could not find TokenNameFinderModel for disease here. I know I can create my own model but I was wondering is there any large sample training data available for disease?
You can easily create your own training data-set using the modelbuilder addon and follow some rules as mentioned here to train create a good NER model.
you can find some help using modelbuilder addon here.
It is basically, you put all the information in a text file and the NER entities in another. The addon searches for a paticular entity and replace it with the required tag. Hence producing the tagged data. It must be pretty easy to use this tool!
Hope this helps!
So, this question might be a little naive, but I thought asking the friendly people of Stackoverflow wouldn't hurt.
My current company has been using a third party API for NLP for a while now. We basically URL encode a string and send it over, and they extract certain entities for us (we have a list of entities that we're looking for) and return a json mapping of entity : sentiment. We've recently decided to bring this project in house instead.
I've been studying NLTK, Stanford NLP and lingpipe for the past 2 days now, and can't figure out if I'm basically reinventing the wheel doing this project.
We already have massive tables containing the original unstructured text and another table containing the extracted entities from that text and their sentiment. The entities are single words. For example:
Unstructured text : Now for the bed. It wasn't the best.
Entity : Bed
Sentiment : Negative
I believe that implies we have training data (unstructured text) as well as entity and sentiments. Now how I can go about using this training data on one of the NLP frameworks and getting what we want? No clue. I've sort of got the steps, but not sure:
Tokenize sentences
Tokenize words
Find the noun in the sentence (POS tagging)
Find the sentiment of that sentence.
But that should fail for the case I mentioned above since it talks about the bed in 2 different sentences?
So the question - Does any one know what the best framework would be for accomplishing the above tasks, and any tutorials on the same (Note: I'm not asking for a solution). If you've done this stuff before, is this task too large to take on? I've looked up some commercial APIs but they're absurdly expensive to use (we're a tiny startup).
Thanks stackoverflow!
OpenNLP may also library to look at. At least they have a small tutuorial to train the name finder and to use the document categorizer to do sentiment analysis. To trtain the name finder you have to prepare training data by taging the entities in your text with SGML tags.
http://opennlp.apache.org/documentation/1.5.3/manual/opennlp.html#tools.namefind.training
NLTK provides a naive NER tagger along with resources. But It doesnt fit into all cases (including finding dates.) But NLTK allows you to modify and customize the NER Tagger according to the requirement. This link might give you some ideas with basic examples on how to customize. Also if you are comfortable with scala and functional programming this is one tool you cannot afford to miss.
Cheers...!
I have discovered spaCy lately and it's just great ! In the link you can find comparative for performance in term of speed and accuracy compared to NLTK, CoreNLP and it does really well !
Though to solve your problem task is not a matter of a framework. You can have two different system, one for NER and one for Sentiment and they can be completely independent. The hype these days is to use neural network and if you are willing too, you can train a recurrent neural network (which has showed best performance for NLP tasks) with attention mechanism to find the entity and the sentiment too.
There are great demo everywhere on the internet, the last two I have read and found interesting are [1] and [2].
Similar to Spacy, TextBlob is another fast and easy package that can accomplish many of these tasks.
I use NLTK, Spacy, and Textblob frequently. If the corpus is simple, generic, and straightforward, Spacy and Textblob work well OOTB. If the corpus is highly customized, domain-specific, messy (incorrect spelling or grammar), etc. I'll use NLTK and spend more time customizing my NLP text processing pipeline with scrubbing, lemmatizing, etc.
NLTK Tutorial: http://www.nltk.org/book/
Spacy Quickstart: https://spacy.io/usage/
Textblob Quickstart: http://textblob.readthedocs.io/en/dev/quickstart.html
I want to categorize comments as positive or negative based on the content.
This is a problem of NLP(Natural Lang Processing) and i am finding difficulties in implementing this.
Check out this blog post. The author describes how to build a Twitter Sentiment Classifier with Python and NLTK. Looks like a good start, as sentiment analysis is no easy task with lots of active research going on in the field.
Also search SO for Sentiment Analysis, I believe there already are many useful answers about this topic on the site.
Here is, Combination of Semi Supervised co-occurance based and unsupervised WSD based classifier. Its in Python though. And you need nltk, wordnet, SentiWord-net and movie review corpus which comes with nltk.
https://github.com/kevincobain2000/sentiment_classifier
The problem is quite complex, anyway I love Pattern: http://www.clips.ua.ac.be/pages/pattern-examples-elections
If you are not categorizing a lot of comments you may wish to try using the chatterboax API
Else you can use Linpipe, but you will have to train your models
I am embarking upon a NLP project for sentiment analysis.
I have successfully installed NLTK for python (seems like a great piece of software for this). However,I am having trouble understanding how it can be used to accomplish my task.
Here is my task:
I start with one long piece of data (lets say several hundred tweets on the subject of the UK election from their webservice)
I would like to break this up into sentences (or info no longer than 100 or so chars) (I guess i can just do this in python??)
Then to search through all the sentences for specific instances within that sentence e.g. "David Cameron"
Then I would like to check for positive/negative sentiment in each sentence and count them accordingly
NB: I am not really worried too much about accuracy because my data sets are large and also not worried too much about sarcasm.
Here are the troubles I am having:
All the data sets I can find e.g. the corpus movie review data that comes with NLTK arent in webservice format. It looks like this has had some processing done already. As far as I can see the processing (by stanford) was done with WEKA. Is it not possible for NLTK to do all this on its own? Here all the data sets have already been organised into positive/negative already e.g. polarity dataset http://www.cs.cornell.edu/People/pabo/movie-review-data/ How is this done? (to organise the sentences by sentiment, is it definitely WEKA? or something else?)
I am not sure I understand why WEKA and NLTK would be used together. Seems like they do much the same thing. If im processing the data with WEKA first to find sentiment why would I need NLTK? Is it possible to explain why this might be necessary?
I have found a few scripts that get somewhat near this task, but all are using the same pre-processed data. Is it not possible to process this data myself to find sentiment in sentences rather than using the data samples given in the link?
Any help is much appreciated and will save me much hair!
Cheers Ke
The movie review data has already been marked by humans as being positive or negative (the person who made the review gave the movie a rating which is used to determine polarity). These gold standard labels allow you to train a classifier, which you could then use for other movie reviews. You could train a classifier in NLTK with that data, but applying the results to election tweets might be less accurate than randomly guessing positive or negative. Alternatively, you can go through and label a few thousand tweets yourself as positive or negative and use this as your training set.
For a description of using Naive Bayes for sentiment analysis with NLTK: http://streamhacker.com/2010/05/10/text-classification-sentiment-analysis-naive-bayes-classifier/
Then in that code, instead of using the movie corpus, use your own data to calculate word counts (in the word_feats method).
Why dont you use WSD. Use Disambiguation tool to find senses. and use map polarity to the senses instead of word. In this case you will get a bit more accurate results as compared to word index polarity.