I'm trying to understand how a MERN app fully works, I've been reading about MongoDB, ExpressJs, ReactJs and NodeJs, I also understand how MongoDB, ExpressJs and NodeJs interact and how ReactJs works on its own, my question is simple (I think).
The question:
If I create an API, using Node,Express and Mongo, and I have an APP managed by React, both need a server (via express, I understand), then, how should I run the API and the React app at the same time. Do I need different URLs? should I configure different ports? how should I integrate them?
I really been reading a lot, but almost every tutorial is made locally (and I'm working in a server with Passenger and I can't change the way it starts), just for Node/Express(with pug or else)/Mongo or just React, and I don't understand how to connect the API and React.
Thanks
It depends on several factors: environment (e.g. development, production), and your control over the server. For development, you can have two different URLs and use something like Webpack Dev Server. Normally you would have the module bundler, e.g. Webpack, watching for changes in your React code. However, this can get more complex if you have Server Side Rendering.
For production, normally you would have the bundled file for your client side application already optimized and minified. If you can change your API, you could serve it statically in a new endpoint, for example: /static/bundle.js and request this endpoint from your index.html file, which will be sent by Express.js server when accessing /.
However, because you will probably want to have routes in your React app, your server will need to know how to handle the client app routes (for example app.get('/*', () => ...), and they could collide with your API endpoints. To solve this, you could:
Prefix your API endpoints with a namespace, e.g. /api/v1/...
Place the API in a different URL, port or subdomain. In this case you would indeed need to run these two servers in parallel. With Node.js, there are helpers to make this more convenient, e.g. concurrently.
Pulling out your concerns: API, React, and Integration for MERN app.
I use three approaches
1) Use foreman. With this, you can specify your API and Web Client in the Procfile. I used it here
2) Use a proxy to handle requests that require your API. So in package.json, you specify your API URL(your API must be running)
// package.json
.......
.......
"proxy": "<path to url:[port no if you're developing locally]>"
Check here.
And you can simply add a script to run your API and React concurrently.
3) Set your API and React app in a Docker container. mern-starter is a perfect place to check for this.
Hope this helps!
Related
I want to use React for a project I am working on, but I also want to use an API.
How can I do it?
I have tried to Google this and ask different people, but I have not got a response yet, so I thought I would ask here. I want to use express and maybe not use create-react-app (as it takes up a lot of storage).
Working on a custom server doesen't preclude the use of an API.
If you want fetch the API from the express server and inject it directly on react frontend you need to enable server side rendering (useful post) and pass the data collected as a props from the server (check this example).
Rather then you can build your react project (using even create-react-app) and build an express server who return the index.html on call.
Personally I prefer the first one solution.
I'm new to Apollo and JS on the server, but not new to React, GraphQL, etc. I'm trying to wrap my head around a clean way of having the server serve both the API, using Apollo, but also the client, which would be built with ReactJS and also Apollo.
I read the article on server-side rendering for Apollo. I might be interested in that in the future, but right now, I'm only interested in having a single project, deployed from a single server, instead of two.
Is it possible to do this cleanly? Is there a canonical way of doing it? can it use create-react-app or is that out of the question?
If you're not doing server-side rendering and just want to serve a Single Page Application (SPA) like what's built with CRA, you can do so using pretty much any HTTP framework or even without one. CRA just builds some static content for you, which you can serve using, for example, Express (see docs here). However, it's typically better to utilize Nginx or Apache for serving this content (at least in production). If you want to utilize Express or another HTTP framework to serve the files, you can utilize the appropriate integration for Apollo Server. If you're using Nginx, then you can stick with the standalone library, assuming you don't want to expose any additional routes on your HTTP server.
In development, you don't want to have to constantly manually rebuild your React application when you make changes, so CRA actually runs a server for you that serves the app and enables hot reloading. Because this is a separate server from your API server, you'll typically want to enable proxying your requests to the API.
It's possible, the setup for apollo is the same as any server, for example, you can use express to serve static files and implement apollo with some minor changes see the docs for apollo server express and implement the one that you are familiar with
I'm currently working on a new ReactJS application. In all the previous applications I've built I used Express for the server side rendering. I used Express because routing in production mode wouldn't work if I didn't.
So I've recently discovered that it's posible to just always redirect my React app to my index.html file and let the React routing just do it's work. This also works when I deploy my application to production.
I know Express can be usefull for SEO porposes but other than that I have no idea why I would need to use it. So am I just missing something? Or is it just fine to don't use Express with my React application if I don't need any SEO.
React configured as a Single Page App, renders the express routing all but unnecessary. The standard transition from a web server rendered app to a single page app is to change the server into a REST Web API and any server side data needed from the React App is obtained through AJAX calls.
So in most cases you don't need Express when you are using React to handle your routing except for in less common cases when you might want to use express as a reverse proxy or something.
If you want to do server-side rendering, you'll need a node server (typically but doesn't have to be express) to render your React components. This could not only help with SEO but also allow your page to appear to load faster (you wouldn't have to wait for the JS to download and run before the user sees the HTML).
If you don't care about the benefits, don't use SSR.
when deploying react application it is just usually an html and a JS file. So you need some kind of server to host it. Luckily there are services out there that offers that like S3, Github etc.
You're using Express because it can host the html and js files. So technically you don't need specifically express but you need some server that will host your files.
I am currently working on a small project where I used vue.js to build the front end and express.js for the backend.
For the frontend, I have another express server to just serve the static files and all the requests will be redirected to my backend API with proxy by the frontend server.
For the backend, it is just an Express API app.
Both apps are runing on heroku right now. And my questions is:
What is the best practice to connect the front end and back end server, I did a lot of research online and people are saying backend API are not supposed to be exposed to internet？ I am not sure how I can talk to my backend if it is not on internet.
For the frontend, I can use SSL/TLS to protect the connection. But for frontend to backend server communication, what should I do to protect this data transfer, can I use another SSL/TLS? And should I use some mechanism to verify that the request is sent from my frontend server, not somewhere else? If so, what is the recommanded way to do that?
A lot people say that there should not be direct connection with database, it should go through a web service for security. What does that means? Now in my backend Express app, I have line of mongoose.connect('mongodb://someaddress/myapp'); Is this bad practice? If so, what should I do to make it more secure?
Please try to be more specific, I am still new to theses and try to learn, code examples can really help. Much appreciated!!
Vue and Express apps are written in the same language, so it is best practice to have these as separate projects as you have done. These are entirely different projects doing different things so they should be split.
You already deployed to Heroku, so the SSL/TLS isn't really a concern for you. However if you were deploying to your own VPS, you'd want something like Let's Encrypt. For restricting requests from Express to your Vue app, you'll want to look into CORS. See expressjs/cors for more details.
The Express app is the service connecting to your database. If you were trying to directly connect to your database from your Vue app, then that becomes an issue. You would coupling client side code with server side code. What you're doing is fine.
I am working on a project that requires developing a SPA using React, Node and Express. I understand Node/Express can serve static files and so my initial thought was I will write a react app and serve it via Express server.
But my Node/Express server also has other roles like, connecting with other microservices and fetch data, which will eventually passed to the UI controlled by react SPA.Sort of a controller! I am also planning to use Graphql instead of Rest.
Will the approach of using the Express server to do both serving the SPA and as a controller has any complication, or should I separate them as two different webapps.
I couldn't find many usecases for my first approach (keeping both together),but I could see that splitting them as two,like here https://dev-blog.apollodata.com/full-stack-react-graphql-tutorial-582ac8d24e3b
Any suggestions on what is the right approach?
Thanks
If you just wanna serve a static file you can use Amazon S3 bucket to serve your React app and throw a a CDN in front of it for optimal load times.
Its nice to keep the separated but it also depends on the size and scope of the project. If you wanna expand it later it might hurt that your API is also serving the app and all its assets.
Where as separating them will split the load from actual API usage and static asset requests (images, index.html ect...).