Excel combine Vlookups - excel

Question

I have two files one is a Project Register that holds key information on a project and the other is a Risk log.
There is a 1:m relationship between entries in the Register and the Risk log. What I need to do is combine all of a project risks into one cell inside the project register file.
The matching field in both files is the Project ID field
Is there a way I can do this using a vlookup variant or multiple nested vlookups?

Answer 1

Here's the user-defined function approach I mentioned (adapted from a different VLOOKUP-variant I already had made):
' Acts like VLOOKUP in a 1-to-many scenario by concatenating all values in matching rows
' instead of just returning the first match
Public Function VLOOKUP_MANY(lookup_value As String, lookup_range As Range, column_number As Integer, Optional delimiter As Variant) As Variant
Dim vArr As Variant
Dim i As Long
Dim found As Boolean: found = False
' Set default delimiter
If IsMissing(delimiter) Then delimiter = ", "
' Get values
vArr = lookup_range.Value2
' If column_number is outside of the specified range, return #REF
If column_number < LBound(vArr, 2) Or column_number > UBound(vArr, 2) Then
VLOOKUP_MANY = CVErr(xlErrRef)
Exit Function
End If
' Search for matches and build a concatenated list
VLOOKUP_MANY = ""
For i = 1 To UBound(vArr, 1)
If UCase(vArr(i, 1)) = UCase(lookup_value) Then
VLOOKUP_MANY = VLOOKUP_MANY & delimiter & vArr(i, column_number)
found = True ' Mark at least 1 result
End If
Next
If found Then
VLOOKUP_MANY = Right(VLOOKUP_MANY, Len(VLOOKUP_MANY) - Len(delimiter)) ' Remove first delimiter
Else
VLOOKUP_MANY = CVErr(xlErrNA) ' If no matches found, return #N/A
End If
End Function
This will search the first column in the specified range for the specified value (same as VLOOKUP), but returns the values in the specified column number concatenated. It will return #N/A when no matches are found, and #REF if an invalid value is specified for the column number (e.g. you choose column 5 but only had a 4-column table).
In case you don't know about user-defined functions - you can just copy this VBA code into the VBE for a module in your workbook. Hit Alt+F11, go to Insert > Module at the top of the screen, then paste this code into the blank file that opens up. When you go to save, you'll have to save your workbook as Macro-Enabled (.xlsm) to keep the code working - Excel will remind you about this in the save screen.
Be forewarned: it's going to be slower than VLOOKUP as a result of having to look through the entire lookup range instead of being able to stop at the first match it finds.
If you're open to using an array formula instead, there are ways to speed up this sort of functionality for very large datasets...
Different version that leverages some of the benefits of array formulas to store lookup values and speedup subsequent calls:
' Acts like VLOOKUP in a 1-to-many scenario by concatenating all values in matching rows
' instead of just returning the first match
' Utilizes a dictionary to speedup multiple matches (great for array formulas)
Public Function VLOOKUP_MANY_ARRAY(lookup_values As Range, lookup_range As Range, column_number As Integer, Optional delimiter As Variant) As Variant
Dim vHaystack As Variant, vNeedles As Variant
Dim i As Long
Dim found As Boolean: found = False
Dim dict As Object: Set dict = CreateObject("Scripting.Dictionary")
' Set default delimiter
If IsMissing(delimiter) Then delimiter = ", "
' Get values
vHaystack = lookup_range
vNeedles = lookup_values
' If column_number is outside of the specified range, return #REF
If column_number < LBound(vHaystack, 2) Or column_number > UBound(vHaystack, 2) Then
VLOOKUP_MANY_ARRAY = CVErr(xlErrRef)
Exit Function
End If
' Add values to a lookup dictionary
For i = 1 To UBound(vHaystack, 1)
If dict.Exists(UCase(vHaystack(i, 1))) Then
dict.Item(UCase(vHaystack(i, 1))) = dict.Item(UCase(vHaystack(i, 1))) & delimiter & vHaystack(i, column_number)
Else
dict.Add UCase(vHaystack(i, 1)), vHaystack(i, column_number)
End If
Next
Dim outArr As Variant
If IsArray(vNeedles) Then ' Check number of lookup cells
' Build output array
ReDim outArr(1 To UBound(vNeedles, 1), 1 To 1) As Variant
For i = 1 To UBound(vNeedles, 1)
If dict.Exists(UCase(vNeedles(i, 1))) Then
outArr(i, 1) = dict.Item(UCase(vNeedles(i, 1)))
Else
outArr(i, 1) = CVErr(xlErrNA)
End If
Next
Else
' Single output value
If dict.Exists(UCase(vNeedles)) Then
outArr = dict.Item(UCase(vNeedles))
Else
outArr = CVErr(xlErrNA)
End If
End If
VLOOKUP_MANY_ARRAY = outArr
End Function
This creates a Dictionary, which is a special structure that's really good for looking up values. There's a little extra overhead involved in building it, but once you have the structure, you can do lookups into it very quickly. This is especially nice with array formulas, which is basically when the exact same formula gets put into a whole collection of cells, then the function executes once and returns values for every cell (instead of just executing once, separately, for a bunch of cells). Enter it like an array formula with CTRL+SHIFT+ENTER, and make the first argument refer to all your lookup values instead of just one.
It will work without being used as an array formula, but it will be somewhat slower than the first function in that situation. However, if you use it in an array formula, you'll see huge speedups.

Answer 2

RE-EDIT:
You might need to write a user defined function or write a macro (code on same link)