How to modify the Verilog code to avoid multiple drivers? - verilog

Question

Quartus 11.0 says:
Error (10028): Can't resolve multiple constant drivers for net "n[9]"
for the following code:
module make_counter(h, clk, P);
input wire h;
input wire clk;
output wire P;
reg r=1'b1;
reg[9:0] n=10'b0000000000;
always #(posedge h)
begin
n<=0;
end
always #(negedge clk)
begin
if(n<600)
n<=n+1'b1;
if(n==106)
r<=1'b0;
else if(n==517)
r<=1'b1;
else;
end
assign P=r;
endmodule
########### image is here ###########
zhe image is what i want. when flag1 start set n=0, and count clk;
when count to flag2, set P=0; when count to red arrow, set P=1;

Answer 1

Assuming h is synchronous to clk, simply sample h and figure out when the sample value is low and the current value is high (e.g. h rose). This way n is assigned within one always block (which is required for synthesis) and everything is is the same clocking domain.
always #(negedge clk) begin
past_h <= h;
if(!past_h && h) begin // detect 0->1
n <= 10'h000;
end
else begin
n <= n + 1'b1;
end
end
If h is asynchronous, then things get more complicated to keep the signal clean. In which case I recommend reading Clock Domain Crossing (CDC) Design & Verification Techniques by Cliff Cummings

Answer 2

As the warning says, there are multiple drivers for n[9], and actually all of n and r, since n and r are both driven in the initial and the always, and when synthesizing the design, there can be only one driver for a reg. And n is driven in multiple always blocks.
For synthesis, a reg should be driven from only one always block.
For the multiple always blocks where n is driven, combine these to only one, and use only one clock, e.g. clk.
If the purpose is to assign a default value for n and r, then make that in the declaration, and remove the initial, like:
reg r = 1'b1;
reg[9:0] n = 0;
However, consider adding a reset signal if possible, then then use this reset signal to assign reset values to the regs, either synchronously or asynchronously.

Answer 3

You can try to move the posedge h into the same always block as the negedge clock and sample h and clk based on the input logic. If h goes low before the negedge of clk then something like this may work.
module make_counter(h, clk, P);
input wire h;
input wire clk;
output wire P;
reg r=1'b1;
reg[9:0] n=10'b0000000000;
always #(negedge clk, posedge h)
begin
if(h==1'b1)
n<=0;
if(n<600)
n<=n+1'b1;
if(n==106)
r<=1'b0;
else if(n==517)
r<=1'b1;
else;
end
assign P=r;
endmodule

Answer 4

i think it will help you out. i have compiled this one in xilinx 14.5 synthesis is done.
module make_counter(h, clk, P);
input wire h;
input wire clk;
output wire P;
reg r=1'b1;
reg[9:0] n=10'b0000000000;
task cpu_write;
begin
# (posedge h);
n <= 0;
# (posedge clk);
if(n<600)
n<=n+1'b1;
if(n==106)
r<=1'b0;
else if(n==517)
r<=1'b1;
else;
end
endtask
assign P=r;
endmodule