RxJs Observable Pagination - pagination

Question

First: This is the first project in which I am using RxJs, I thought I will learn best by using it.
I found this answer: Turning paginated requests into an Observable stream with RxJs
But it says in the comments:
You're exceeding the maximum call stack still. At around 430 pages returned. I think recursion might not be the best solution here
I want to query the Youtube Data API, the results come back in pages and I need to paginate through them.
I imagined a work flow like this could work:
1)Initiate a call
2)Check if the response has a 'nextPageToken'
3)If it has, do another request to the Youtube API
4)If not, finish
So to do this I could Imagine the following Observables / streams:
FirstRequestStream -A-X--------------->
ResponseStream -A-A-A-A--X-------->
RequestStream -I-A-I-A----------->
A = Action
I = Info from upper stream
X = Termination
(Not sure if this diagram is correct the way I made it)
So the ResponseStream depends on FirstRequestStream and RequestStream(using the merge function). The RequestStream depends on the ResponseStream( is this called a circulating observable ?)
-Is this the right approach ?
-Are 'circulating observables' a good thing, are they even possible ?(I had problems creating one).
-Any other way I should try first?
-Is it possible to create interdependent observable streams ?
Thank you for your help.

Answer 1

You are overcomplicating this problem, it can be solved a lot easier using defer operator.
Idea is that you are creating deferred observable (so it will be created and start fetching data only after subscription) and concatenate it with the same observable but for the next page, which will be also concatenated with the next page, and so on ... . And all of that can be done without recursion.
Here is how the code looks:
const { defer, from, concat, EMPTY, timer } = rxjs; // = require("rxjs")
const { mergeMap, take, mapTo, tap } = rxjs.operators; // = require("rxjs/operators")
// simulate network request
function fetchPage(page=0) {
return timer(100).pipe(
tap(() => console.log(`-> fetched page ${page}`)),
mapTo({
items: Array.from({ length: 10 }).map((_, i) => page * 10 + i),
nextPage: page + 1,
})
);
}
const getItems = page => defer(() => fetchPage(page)).pipe(
mergeMap(({ items, nextPage }) => {
const items$ = from(items);
const next$ = nextPage ? getItems(nextPage) : EMPTY;
return concat(items$, next$);
})
);
// process only first 30 items, without fetching all of the data
getItems()
.pipe(take(30))
.subscribe(e => console.log(e));
<script src="https://unpkg.com/rxjs#6.2.2/bundles/rxjs.umd.min.js"></script>

Answer 2

Here is my solution using the rxjs operators expand, reduce and empty using the HttpClient module:
Suppose your API response is an object containing shaped like the following
interface Response {
data: items[]; // array of result items
next: string|null; // url of next page, or null if there are no more items
}
You could use expand and reduce like so
getAllResults(url) {
return this.http.get(url).pipe(
expand((res) => res.next ? this.http.get(res.next) : EMPTY),
reduce((acc, res) => acc.concat(res.data), [])
);
}

Answer 3

I shamelessly reuse the code snippet from Oles Savluk, with its good fetchPage function, and I apply the ideas explained in the blog article linked to by Picci (in the comments), using expand.
Article on expand by Nicholas Jamieson
It gives a slightly simpler code, with recursion hidden in the expand call (and comments of the article show how to linearize it, if needed).
const { timer, EMPTY } = rxjs; // = require("rxjs")
const { concatMap, expand, mapTo, tap, toArray } = rxjs.operators; // = require("rxjs/operators")
// simulate network request
const pageNumber = 3;
function fetchPage(page = 0) {
return timer(1000).pipe(
tap(() => console.log(`-> fetched page ${page}`)),
mapTo({
items: Array.from({ length: 10 }).map((_, i) => page * 10 + i),
nextPage: ++page === pageNumber ? undefined : page,
}),
);
}
const list = fetchPage().pipe(
expand(({ nextPage }) => nextPage ? fetchPage(nextPage) : EMPTY),
concatMap(({ items }) => items),
// Transforms the stream of numbers (Observable<number>)
// to a stream with only an array of numbers (Observable<number[]>).
// Remove if you want a stream of numbers, not waiting for all requests to complete.
toArray(),
);
list.subscribe(console.log);
<script src="https://unpkg.com/rxjs#6.2.2/bundles/rxjs.umd.min.js"></script>

Answer 4

LuJaks is definitively the simplest approach !
For a one line example, suppose you have a function that make a http request for a given page and that returns a (partial) array of data. We call that function until server returns empty array :
import { Observable, EMPTY, of } from "rxjs";
import { expand, reduce } from "rxjs/operators";
// Mock a request that returns only 5 pages...
function httpGet(p): Observable<number[]> {
if (p > 5) { return of([]); }
return of(new Array(10).fill(0).map((_, i) => p * 10 + i));
}
httpGet(0).pipe( // get the fist page
expand((value, index) => (value.length > 0 ? httpGet(index + 1) : EMPTY)), // other pages
reduce((a, v) => [...a, ...v], []), // optional if you want only one emit
).subscribe((x) => console.log(x));