Redirecting stdout to file nodejs - node.js

Question

I've created:
var access = fs.createWriteStream('/var/log/node/api.access.log', { flags: 'w' });
Then piped:
process.stdout.pipe(access);
Then tried:
console.log("test");
And nothing has appeared in /var/log/node/api.access.log. However this way is working:
process.stdout.pipe(access).write('test');
Could someone explain what am I doing wrong ?

Answer 1

I solved this problem the following way:
var access = fs.createWriteStream('/var/log/node/api.access.log');
process.stdout.write = process.stderr.write = access.write.bind(access);
Of course you can also separate stdout and stderr if you want.
I also would strongly recommend to handle uncaught exceptions:
process.on('uncaughtException', function(err) {
console.error((err && err.stack) ? err.stack : err);
});
This will cover the following situations:
process.stdout.write
process.stderr.write
console.log
console.dir
console.error
someStream.pipe(process.stdout);
throw new Error('Crash');
throw 'never do this';
throw undefined;

Answer 2

Checkout console.Console, the parent class of the normal console.
var myLogFileStream = fs.createWriteStream(pathToMyLogFile);
var myConsole = new console.Console(myLogFileStream, myLogFileStream);
You can then you use myConsole.log, myConsole.error, myConsole.dir, etc. and write directly to your file.
You can also monkey patch process.stdout.write as follows:
var fn = process.stdout.write;
function write() {
fn.apply(process.stdout, arguments);
myLogFileStream.write.apply(myLogFileStream, arguments);
}
process.stdout.write = write;
there are also other options for overwriting console._stdout depending on the motivation for logging the stdout to a file.

Answer 3

process.stdout is a Writable. pipe is a method of Readable(Cf StreamAPI documentation : https://nodejs.org/api/stream.html
You can see the documentation of process.stdout here : https://nodejs.org/api/process.html#process_process_stdout
It's surprising that you can do process.stdout.pipe(...); without any error. But i suppose this call just do nothing. Except returning a new Writable stream binded to stdout (or maybe it returns process.stdout itself. There's no specification for that in the documentation).
If you want to redirect stdout to a file, you have many solutions :
Just use your command line to do that. Windows style : node myfile.js > api.access.log.
Replace the console object by your own object. And you can rewrite console methods.
I'm not sure, but it may be possible to replace process.stdout with your own stream (and you can do whatever you want with this)

Answer 4

#user3173842
for the reply on
I solved this problem the following way:
var access = fs.createWriteStream('/var/log/node/api.access.log');
process.stdout.write = process.stderr.write = access.write.bind(access);
you do understand that process.stdout continues after process.on('exit') and therefore the fs.WriteStream closes after with process.stdout, according to
https://github.com/nodejs/node/issues/7606
so now the question remains, if the developer desired to have the fs.Writestream.write() return to its normal functionality and when fs.Writestream.end is called the writestream closes. How would the developer go about doing this I did
a_l = asyncify_listener
p_std_stream_m is a process stream manager object
p_std_stream_m.std_info.p_stdout_write = process.stdout.write
process.stdout.write = w_stream.write.bind(w_stream)
process.once('beforeExit', a_l( p_std_stream_m.handler,process.stdout,w_stream ) )
where in the 'beforeExit' event listener I did
process.stdout.write = p_std_stream_m.std_info.p_stdout_write
w_stream.end()
It works and you use the once method because the process.stdout seems to do a lot of work
at this time.
Is this good practice, would you do this or what would you do in this situation
anyone can feel free to reply.

Answer 5

Originally based on #Anatol-user3173842 answer
But in my case I needed to hook the stdout & stderr and also write into a file.
So for those who need to keep the normal stdout behaviour in addition to writing into the file. Use the following.
For non-errors:
// stdout logging hook
const stdoutWrite0 = process.stdout.write;
process.stdout.write = (args) => { // On stdout write
CustomLogger.writeToLogFile('log', args); // Write to local log file
args = Array.isArray(args) ? args : [args]; // Pass only as array to prevent internal TypeError for arguments
return stdoutWrite0.apply(process.stdout, args);
};
For errors:
// stderr logging hook
const stderrWrite0 = process.stderr.write;
process.stderr.write = (args) => { // On stderr write
CustomLogger.writeToLogFile('error', args); // Write to local error file
args = Array.isArray(args) ? args : [args]; // Pass only as array to prevent internal TypeError for arguments
return stderrWrite0.apply(process.stderr, args);
};
// uncaught exceptions
process.on('uncaughtException', (err) => {
CustomLogger.writeToLogFile('error', ((err && err.stack) ? err.stack : err));
});
Here is the CustomLogger code, where I also separate the log files by date:
export class CustomLogger {
static LOGS_DIR = 'location-of-my-log-files';
private static logDailyName(prefix: string): string {
const date = new Date().toLocaleDateString().replace(/\//g, '_');
return `${CustomLogger.LOGS_DIR}/${prefix}_${date}.log`;
}
private static writeToLogFile(prefix, originalMsg) {
const timestamp = Date.now();
const fileName = this.logDailyName(prefix);
const logMsg = prepareForLogFile(originalMsg);
fs.appendFileSync(fileName, `${timestamp}\t${logMsg}\n\n`);
return originalMsg;
}
}

Answer 6

Here's a quick example of a logger class that redirects stdout, stderr and exceptions to a file, while still writting everything to the console:
class Logger {
#log_stream
#stdout_write
#stderr_write
constructor(path) {
this.#log_stream = fs.createWriteStream(path, { flags: 'a' })
this.#stdout_write = process.stdout.write.bind(process.stdout)
this.#stderr_write = process.stderr.write.bind(process.stderr)
process.stdout.write = this.stdout_write.bind(this)
process.stderr.write = this.stderr_write.bind(this)
process.on('uncaughtException', function(err) {
console.error((err && err.stack) ? err.stack : err)
})
}
stdout_write(buffer) {
this.#log_stream.write(buffer)
this.#stdout_write(buffer)
}
stderr_write(buffer) {
this.#log_stream.write(buffer)
this.#stderr_write(buffer)
}
}
const logger = new Logger('example.log')