scikit-learn roc_curve: why does it return a threshold value = 2 some time? - scikit-learn

Question

Correct me if I'm wrong: the "thresholds" returned by scikit-learn's roc_curve should be an array of numbers that are in [0,1]. However, it sometimes gives me an array with the first number close to "2". Is it a bug or I did sth wrong? Thanks.
In [1]: import numpy as np
In [2]: from sklearn.metrics import roc_curve
In [3]: np.random.seed(11)
In [4]: aa = np.random.choice([True, False],100)
In [5]: bb = np.random.uniform(0,1,100)
In [6]: fpr,tpr,thresholds = roc_curve(aa,bb)
In [7]: thresholds
Out[7]:
array([ 1.97396826, 0.97396826, 0.9711752 , 0.95996265, 0.95744405,
0.94983331, 0.93290463, 0.93241372, 0.93214862, 0.93076592,
0.92960511, 0.92245024, 0.91179548, 0.91112166, 0.87529458,
0.84493853, 0.84068543, 0.83303741, 0.82565223, 0.81096657,
0.80656679, 0.79387241, 0.77054807, 0.76763223, 0.7644911 ,
0.75964947, 0.73995152, 0.73825262, 0.73466772, 0.73421299,
0.73282534, 0.72391126, 0.71296292, 0.70930102, 0.70116428,
0.69606617, 0.65869235, 0.65670881, 0.65261474, 0.6487222 ,
0.64805644, 0.64221486, 0.62699782, 0.62522484, 0.62283401,
0.61601839, 0.611632 , 0.59548669, 0.57555854, 0.56828967,
0.55652111, 0.55063947, 0.53885029, 0.53369398, 0.52157349,
0.51900774, 0.50547317, 0.49749635, 0.493913 , 0.46154029,
0.45275916, 0.44777116, 0.43822067, 0.43795921, 0.43624093,
0.42039077, 0.41866343, 0.41550367, 0.40032843, 0.36761763,
0.36642721, 0.36567017, 0.36148354, 0.35843793, 0.34371331,
0.33436415, 0.33408289, 0.33387442, 0.31887024, 0.31818719,
0.31367915, 0.30216469, 0.30097917, 0.29995201, 0.28604467,
0.26930354, 0.2383461 , 0.22803687, 0.21800338, 0.19301808,
0.16902881, 0.1688173 , 0.14491946, 0.13648451, 0.12704826,
0.09141459, 0.08569481, 0.07500199, 0.06288762, 0.02073298,
0.01934336])

Answer 1

Most of the time these thresholds are not used, for example in calculating the area under the curve, or plotting the False Positive Rate against the True Positive Rate.
Yet to plot what looks like a reasonable curve, one needs to have a threshold that incorporates 0 data points. Since Scikit-Learn's ROC curve function need not have normalised probabilities for thresholds (any score is fine), setting this point's threshold to 1 isn't sufficient; setting it to inf is sensible but coders often expect finite data (and it's possible the implementation also works for integer thresholds). Instead the implementation uses max(score) + epsilon where epsilon = 1. This may be cosmetically deficient, but you haven't given any reason why it's a problem!

Answer 2

From the documentation:
thresholds : array, shape = [n_thresholds]
Decreasing thresholds on the decision function used to compute
fpr and tpr. thresholds[0] represents no instances being predicted
and is arbitrarily set to max(y_score) + 1.
So the first element of thresholds is close to 2 because it is max(y_score) + 1, in your case thresholds[1] + 1.

Answer 3

this seems like a bug to me - in roc_curve(aa,bb), 1 is added to the first threshold. You should create an issue here https://github.com/scikit-learn/scikit-learn/issues