How do I link ".a" fat-static-libs with Apportable?
In the beginning, I did get a warning,
Warning: Library not found for lib-name. Try adding this to the
'deps' array in the 'add_params' section of your configuration.json
file. Check ~/.apportable/SDK/System for the directory names that
correspond to 'deps' entries.
I did add it to "deps" in the JSON right where it says this:
// A list of dependencies. Typically these correspond to frameworks in the xcode project.
My library isn't a framework, though. It's just a .a static library that has armv7, armv7s, and i386 parts which I assembled using lipo from two libraries (an armv7 and armv7s .a and a i386 .a) built with Xcode. They both use a single framework which is this Boost framework.
Adding it under deps squelched that warning message, but the apportable linker is still giving undefined references, so it is still not properly linking this file.
Now I know that Apportable has to re-jitter all this stuff, since Android won't know what to do with a Mac-executable format, so it's probably got to go pick apart my library and possibly turn it into an ELF-library before final linking. I'm not sure how to go about debugging this at this point, but is this supported at all?
Since you get "library not found" that means Apportable simply can't find the file. Hence the problem is merely with the file's location (or existence) and not what's in the library or how it is built.
The most common issue with dependent targets, especially Xcode projects dropped into other Xcode projects respectively workspaces with multiple projects, is that the resulting output of each target/project goes to different folders. Then Apportable (as well as xcodebuild under some circumstances) can't find the resulting libraries.
First step you should try is to make sure that the target dependencies are set. Select the app target, go to the Build Phases pane and under Target Dependencies add all frameworks and libraries that appear in the list and that your project depends on. This should ensure that the dependent frameworks/libraries do get built - because Xcode's built-in automatic dependency resolution isn't available to command line tools from what I understand. So you need to explicitly specify the dependent projects respectively their output.
If that doesn't help, you can force all targets to write their output to the same folder. Under Build Settings for every target change the Build Products Path (symbolic name: SYMROOT) to the same folder, for example ~/myprojectsbuildoutput
That way even dependent other projects will place their output in the same folder and xcodebuild as well as Apportable (it depends on xcodebuild) will be able to find the library files.
Tip: make sure your project builds successfully on the command line. Open Terminal, cd into the folder where the .xcodeproj bundle is and enter xcodebuild. If xcodebuild fails merely due to validation, disable Validate Built Product under Build Settings of the app target. If xcodebuild fails, Apportable likely isn't going to work either because it depends on xcodebuild. So as a prerequisite make sure that xcodebuild works on your project.
If xcodebuild also gives you "library not found" try calling it with a specific SYMROOT:
xcodebuild SYMROOT=~/myprojectsbuildoutput
If that then works you know you have to update each target's Build Projects Path. From what I know it's not currently possible (or not documented) to pass custom xcodebuild parameters via Apportable, so it needs to be set up in the .xcodeproj itself.
Related
Apparently anything GUI-related in terms of components involves XML. I cannot go around actually configuring and building wxWidgets from source because of that. I'm new to wxWidgets.
My current setup is on Win10 with MSVC v141 (Visual Studio 2017) with the latest CMake version (currently 3.21).
Inside the config.cmake of the wxWidgets projects (using latest master branch) I see
wx_get_dependencies(EXTRALIBS_XML xml)
I am also calling CMake with -DwxUSE_XML=ON (among other parameters) but this still leads to:
the XML dependency is nowhere to be found
respectively it's not built
Linking then fails with the following error:
LINK : fatal error LNK1104: cannot open file 'wxxml.lib' [C:\Users\...\CMakeBuilds\ef5b5ada-ee42-7735-988a-ae37c735ccff\build\deps\build\wxwidgets\libs\qa\wxqa.vcxproj]
What library is actually wxWidgets using and how do I trigger it's retrieval and accordingly configuration and building? Since I am adding wxWidgets to my CMake project as an ExternalProject component, I would appreciated something in that line of thought. However any kind of information regarding this issue is more than welcome especially since it will shine light on how to configure other features (if I want them in the future) such as WebView.
The wxxml.lib issue is fixed now. While fixing it I also discovered a bug (of sort) in the build system of wxWidgets.
The reason why it failed to build this library in particular was actually quite simple but due to the lack of knowledge in the dependencies of wxWidgets. I thought that wxWidgets, given it depends on XML so much, has its own XML parser. Well, not really. The wxXML component actually uses and underlying 3rd party dependency called EXPAT, which - as you can see in my question - I have deactivated since it was giving me issues during the build (due to the still present problem of not being able to automatically retrieve dependencies).
What I did was to clone the libexpat repository, add it as an ExternalProject, set the variables for the libraries and include directory and pass them onto my wxWidgets project. But there is a catch...
The expat.cmake file looks as follows:
#############################################################################
# Name: build/cmake/lib/expat.cmake
# Purpose: Use external or internal expat lib
# Author: Tobias Taschner
# Created: 2016-09-21
# Copyright: (c) 2016 wxWidgets development team
# Licence: wxWindows licence
#############################################################################
if(wxUSE_EXPAT STREQUAL "builtin")
# TODO: implement building expat via its CMake file, using
# add_subdirectory or ExternalProject_Add
wx_add_builtin_library(wxexpat
src/expat/expat/lib/xmlparse.c
src/expat/expat/lib/xmlrole.c
src/expat/expat/lib/xmltok.c
)
set(EXPAT_LIBRARIES wxexpat)
set(EXPAT_INCLUDE_DIRS ${wxSOURCE_DIR}/src/expat/expat/lib)
elseif(wxUSE_EXPAT)
find_package(EXPAT REQUIRED)
endif()
I would use the *.cmake files of the 3rd party dependencies stored inside <ROOT_OF_WXWIDGETS_PROJECT>/build/cmake/lib to determine which variables I need to set if builtin is selected as the value for the respective library. Since I want to use my own I need sys (e.g. -DwxUSE_EXPAT=sys as a CMAKE_ARGS inside my wxWidgets ExternalProject) and also to pass the headers and libraries accordingly.
Given the file above one would assume that EXPAT_LIBRARIES is required. However after failing to build (yet again) and seeing that the reason was the activated expat build and that it was set as builtin I checked the log in detail and found the following error:
Could NOT find EXPAT (missing: EXPAT_LIBRARY) (found version "2.2.6")
Notice the EXPAT_LIBRARY. After passing it (-DEXPAT_LIBRARY=...) my build was complete. For me this is a bug or simply inconsistency between the dependency cmake file and the rest of the wxWidgets project.
It is important to note that I do not retrieve the external dependency through wxWidgets itself (see config.cmake and more precisely the macro wx_get_dependencies(...)). This solves the problem with a basic configuration and build of wxWidgets but if you don't want to tackle every dependency of wxWidgets on your own (why should you?), I recommend looking for a solution where the dependencies (at least the ones you don't want to deal with) are automatically retrieved, configured and build as builtin.
Greetings, what I'm trying to do is to port an existing Windows application to Linux using CMake with CMakeLists, which I generated with the vcproj2cmake Script (https://github.com/sixman9/vcproj2cmake).
With the CMakeLists.txt and CMake I was able to successfully port a VS 2005 project to VS 2010. Now I try to port the same VS 2005 project to Linux, so that I can edit it with KDevelope.
The project itself is small and I think it would be easier to just create a new project and copy all relevant files (if that would work), the problem is, that it's not only one project but many, hence I was looking for a way to port a project in an as simple as possible way.
In Linux I was able to create a CMakeLists.txt using the vcproj2cmake script. The next step would be creating a KDevelope project using CMake. And this is where I'm stuck.
Everytime I try to run CMake I get the following error:
CMake Error at CMakeLists.txt: 196 (set_property) :
set_property could not find TARGET Test_Project. Perhaps it has not yet been
created.
Test_Project: installing /root/Desktop/Test_Project/vs8/CMakeLists. txt rebuilder (watching /root/Desktop/Test_Project/vs8/Test_Project. vcproj)
Configuring incomplete, errors occurred!
See also “/root/Desktop/Test_Project/vs8/CMakeFiles/CMakeOutput.log”.
I searched for a solution or an approach for quite a time now, but the only results that I get are project-specific, or at least I think they are.
Content of the CMakeLists.txt from line 196:
set_property(TARGET Test_Project PROPERTY PROJECT_LABEL "Test_Project")
v2c_rebuild_on_update(Test_Project "${CMAKE_CURRENT_SOURCE_DIR}/Test_Project.vcproj" ${CMAKE_CURRENT_LIST_FILE} "vcproj2cmake.rb" ".")
include(${V2C_HOOK_POST} OPTIONAL)
Perhaps there are more efficient ways to port many projects form Windows to Linux, I'm open for any suggestion.
It is a bit difficult to help without having your project - since you are using a third party tool to convert a VC project you should ask the author of that tool. :D
If you have many projects which you are going to maintain, I suggest that you select one where you can create a cross platform (Windows/Linux) CMake config for which you can reuse for other projects.
Most of the config should be the same for all platforms you are building for - the difference should be which generator is used and what libraries to link in the final executable (if you are building one that is). The generator is specified when running cmake.
In my opinion you should try an out of source build with the following structure:
/$COMMON_DIR/CMakeLists.txt
/CMakeLists.txt
/src/
/build/
/build/vcX
/build/generate_vcX.bat
/build/linux
/build/generate_linux.sh
$COMMON_DIR should contain the CMake code you expect to be common for all you projects - like a function to create a static library for a module which searches for files in /src and another function which can be used to add an executable for certain platform.
The CMakeLists.txt in the root of your project (repository, I assume) should call the functions defined in $COMMON_DIR and possibly add some project specific defines or link flags.
All was right in the world until I upgraded to Xcode 4 a few days ago. Since then I've had endless problems getting things to work as they should. And I have a crucial update I need to release. I've tried every permutation of settings I can think of, restarted, reinstalled Xcode, reverted to old versions of my files, everything.
My project links to three static libraries, contained in three other projects. I have used the standard processes to link libraries (drag the project files into mine, add their products as target dependencies, add the lib---.a files to the Link Binary With Libraries phase). And actually, I have no problem compiling with the Debug Build Configuration, either for the simulator or my test device.
Where everything goes sideways is when I compile with the Release Build Configuration, or when I try to Archive. I've gotten many different errors depending on my settings, but most are variations on this:
ld: warning: ignoring file
[...]/Build/Products/Debug-iphonesimulator/libGDataTouchStaticLib.a,
file was built for archive which is
not the architecture being linked
(armv6) Undefined symbols for
architecture armv6:
"_OBJC_CLASS_$_GDataSpreadsheetData",
referenced from:
objc-class-ref in ExportViewController.o
I can't understand why it's even looking at Products in the Debug-iphonesimulator directory (I swear, everything I'm linking to reveals itself in the Finder to be in the proper Release-iphoneos directory).
I have put a ridiculous number of hours into fixing this, really need help! Thank you!
Please check this question and answer. I encountered same problem and fixed it.
Xcode4 Linking Problem. File was built for archive which is not the architecture being linked (arm6)
I solved this problem by copying the .a lib files from the Release-iphoneos directory to the Debug-iphonesimulator directory so that the correct files would be found even though Xcode was looking in the wrong directory.
However, then I encountered the problem raised here of a multi-application bundle -- and the solution given didn't work for me. Finally gave up and reinstalled Xcode 3. Compiled, archived, and uploaded to the App Store in 20 minutes. Will be some time, and several dot-releases, before I give Xcode 4 another shot.
You may have -DGDATA_REQUIRE_SERVICE_INCLUDES=1 enabled in your other C flags for the GDataTouchStaticLib target. If so, add the service you need, in this case, spreadsheets, by adding -DGDATA_INCLUDE_SPREADSHEET_SERVICE=1 to your Other C Flags. Or if you don't want GData to require service includes (which will build everything into the static lib, not just what you need), just remove the DGDATA_REQUIRE_SERVICE_INCLUDES flag.
I'm trying to compile a piece of software which has the standard build process e.g.
configure
make
make install
The software requires a library e.g. libreq.so which is installed in /usr/local/lib. However, my problem is I'd like to build the software and link it with a different version of the same library (i have the source for the library as well) that I've installed in /home/user/mylibs.
My question is, how do I compile and link the software against the library in /home/user/mylibs rather than the one in /usr/local/lib
I tried setting "LD_LIBRARY_PATH" to include /home/user/mylibs but that didn't work.
Thanks!
When you have an autoconf configure script, use:
CPPFLAGS=-I/home/user/include LDFLAGS=-L/home/user/mylibs ./configure ...
This adds the nominated directory to the list of directories searched for headers (usually necessary when you're using a library), and adds the other nominated directory to the list searched for actual libraries.
I use this all the time - on my work machine, /usr/local is 'maintained' by MIS and contains obsolete code 99.9% of the time (and is NFS-mounted, read-only), so I struggle to avoid using it at all and maintain my own, more nearly current, versions of the software under /usr/gnu. It works for me.
Try using LD_PRELOAD set to your actual file.
LD_LIBRARY_PATH is for finding the dynamic link libraries at runtime. At compiling you should add -L parameters to gcc/g++ to specify in which directory the *.so files are. You also need to add the library name with -l<NAME> (where the library is libNAME.so).
Important! For linking you not only need the libNAME.so file but a libNAME.a is needed too.
When you run the application, don't forget to add the dir to the LD_LIBRARY_PATH.
When you added the /home/user/mylibs to the LD_LIBRARY_PATH did you add it to the front or end of the existing paths? The tokens are searched in-order so you will want yours to appear first in the list.
Also, many standard build environments that use configure will allow you to specify an exact library for each required piece. You will have to run ./configure --help but you should see something like --using-BLAH-lib=/path/to/your/library or similar.
I don't know if it's possible to do this, but I would like the /NODEFAULTLIB to be applied to a static library project.
I have many application projects (A.exe, B.dll, C.dll) that use a common static library D.lib.
This library has a lot of code and also has other .lib dependencies as well. One of them is the openssl library, which seems to have been built for win32 against the Release version of the CRT (i don't have the original project/sources).
So far, to avoid the mixing of the Release/Debug versions of CRT, I have to put the /NODEFAULTLIB:msvcrt.lib linker directive in all leaf projects (A.exe, B.dll). This works but I think it's not the ideal way of dealing with that issue.
I tried to put this property in D.lib project, but it has no effect.
Is there a way to force msvc++ to ignore the msvcrt.lib dependency from the 3rd party library?
A .lib does not have any linker settings because you don't link it, you link to it. A .lib is just an archive of .obj files, sort of like an uncompressed .zip file - that's why you have to put the setting on all projects that link to it.
If you're using VS2005+ you could use property sheets so that you only have to put the setting in one place and then use that property sheet in all projects.
However, OpenSSL is just that - Open Source, so you should be able to get the source for the version you are using and build it again (and add it to your version control system of course). I thought OpenSSL could be built as a DLL or LIB, which would solve your problem as the DLL would not interfere with the linking of your code.
Failing that, you always have the option of slitting your functionality out into a separate DLL so that you only have issues with one project.
To prevent your distributed static link library from depending on a specific MSVC runtime library you need to set this compiler option (in Visual Studio 2010 it looks like):
Configuration Properties -> C/C++ -> Advanced -> Omit Default Library Name = Yes (/ZI)
Now your users can link to your release built static lib from their debug build and not try to link to the incorrect runtime library causing problems, as well as linkers warnings.
Note that may cause link errors if your library actually depends on a specific runtime library or its behavior, and compatible components are not provided in some other way.
My understanding is that if library LIB in linked statically into a DLL, the DLL contains already all relevant code from LIB. Therefore, this coupling cannot be removed. This is just based on my understanding of statical linking, not on experiments.