EmailAddress Validation in Java - apache-commons

Question

I was researching best possible way to check if a String was a valid email Address. I am now fixated on two options, viz., using javax.mail.internet.InternetAddress; or using Apache Commons EmailValidator, which internally uses complicated regex parser.
I was wondering if there is any advantages on picking one over the other in terms of correctness, or is both just fine? I know for a fact that InternetAddress doesn't handle non-ascii characters efficiently in some cases.

Answer 1

You can use an EmailValidator from Apache Commons Validator library for that:
import org.apache.commons.validator.EmailValidator;
...
EmailValidator validator = EmailValidator.getInstance();
if (validator.isValid(email)) {
// is valid, do something
} else {
// is invalid, do something
}
isValid method checks if a field has a valid e-mail address.
This is the best Java email address validation method according to this question
What is the best Java email address validation method?

Answer 2

For something as well-established as email address format, the difference between two approaches is minuscule. Then again, fifty years ago, people never saw the need to use 4 digits for encoding years, so...
The only 'pitfall' with using the regex from Apache Commons, is that its functionality for validating an email address isn't "Java standard". To what extent that affects you as a developer? depends on how paranoid you are.
On the other hand, the standard Java implementation might be less efficient. You'd have to construct an InternetAddress and validate it. Looking at JavaMail's source code, I could see this:
/**
* Check that the address is a valid "mailbox" per RFC822.
* (We also allow simple names.)
*
* XXX - much more to check
* XXX - doesn't handle domain-literals properly (but no one uses them)
*/
(The XXX seems to be some sort of a note, or a "to do" item)

Answer 3

I've just tested it, and apparently the performance on InternetAddress is substantially better then using EmailValidator
package com.avaya.oss.server.errors;
import javax.mail.internet.AddressException;
import javax.mail.internet.InternetAddress;
import org.apache.commons.validator.EmailValidator;
public class TestValidationTypes {
static String email = "test#testy.com";
static int maxItr = 10000;
public static void main(String[] args) throws AddressException {
long start = System.currentTimeMillis();
for (int i = 0; i < maxItr; i++) {
EmailValidator.getInstance().isValid(email);
}
System.out.println("EmailValidator duration: " + (System.currentTimeMillis() - start));
start = System.currentTimeMillis();
for (int i = 0; i < maxItr; i++) {
InternetAddress internetAddress = new InternetAddress(email);
internetAddress.validate();
}
System.out.println("InternetAdress duration: " + (System.currentTimeMillis() - start));
}
}
Output:
EmailValidator duration: 1195
InternetAdress duration: 67
The results are that EmailValidator took ~20 times longer: