sed doesn't replace variable - linux

Question

I'm trying to replace some regex line in a apache file.
i define:
OLD1="[0-9]*.[0-9]+"
NEW1="[a-z]*.[0-9]"
when i'm executing:
sed -i 's/$OLD1/$NEW1/g' demo.conf
there's no change.
This is what i tried to do
sed -i "s/${OLD1}/${NEW1}/g" 001-kms.conf
sed -i "s/"$OLD1"/"$NEW1"/g" 001-kms.conf
sed -i "s~${OLD1}~${NEW1}~g" 001-kms.conf
i'm expecting that the new file will replace $OLD1 with $NEW1

Answer 1

OLD1="[0-9]*.[0-9]+"
Because the [ * . are all characters with special meaning in sed, we need to escape them. For such simple case something like this could work:
OLD2=$(<<<"$OLD1" sed 's/[][\*\.]/\\&/g')
It will set OLD2 to \[0-9\]\*\.\[0-9\]+. Note that it doesn't handle all the possible cases, like OLD1='\.\[' will convert to OLD2='\\.\\[ which means something different. Implementing a proper regex to properly escape, well, other regex I leave as an exercise to others.
Now you can:
sed "s/$OLD2/$NEW1/g"
Tested with:
OLD1="[0-9]*.[0-9]+"
NEW1="[a-z]*.[0-9]"
sed "s/$(sed 's/[][\*\.]/\\&/g' <<<"$OLD1")/$NEW1/g" <<<'XYZ="[0-9]*.[0-9]+"'
will output:
XYZ="[a-z]*.[0-9]"

Answer 2

you need matching on exact string
You would need something that can match on exact string [0-9]*.[0-9]+ which sed does not support well.
Therefore instead I am using this pipeline replacing one character at a time (it also is easier to read I think):echo "[0-9]*.[0-9]+" | sed 's/0/a/' | sed 's/9/z/' | sed 's/+//'
You would have to cat your files or use find with execute to then apply this pipe.
I had tried following (from other SO answers):
- sed 's/\<exact_string/>/replacement/'doesn't work as \< and \> are left and right word boundaries respectively.
- sed 's/(CB)?exact_string/replacement/'found in one answer but nowhere in documentation
I used Win 10 bash, git bash, and online Linux tools with the same results.
when I thought matching was on the pattern rather than exact string
Replacement cannot be a regex - at most it can reference parts of the regex expression which matched. From man sed:
s/regexp/replacement/
Attempt to match regexp against the pattern space. If successful, replace that portion matched with replacement. The replacement may contain the special character & to refer to that portion of the pattern space which matched, and the special escapes \1 through \9 to refer to the corresponding matching sub-expressions in the regexp.
Additionally you have to escape some characters in your regex (specifically . and +) unless you add option -E for extended regex as per comment under your question. (N.B. only if you want to match on the full-stop . rather than it meaning any character)
$ echo "01.234--ZZZ" | sed 's/[0-9]*\.[0-9]\+/REPLACEMENT/g'
REPLACEMENT--ZZZ