Creating an Index(Match()) for Multiple Criteria, with Multiple Results for Multiple Dates - excel

Question

The solution to this problem has been evading me and admittedly hurting my brain a little bit, so hopefully someone here can lend a hand. Essentially, I have around 10 columns of data. One of these columns contains the identifier I want to use, another column has the date I want to reference, and the rest of the columns are the values I want to use to populate the table. What I'm trying to do is build a tool where you type in the identifier and the date and it tells you what the other columns are for that particular pairing.
The problem is, however, that the data set contains multiple repeated dates (dates are in a column), and sometimes repeated identifiers. So identifier 1 may appear three times on 1/1/2018, then appear three more times on 1/2/2018.
Forgive my inexperience, as this is probably the incorrect way to show this, but this is what I want my data to look like, with the bins being the 1st, 2nd, and so on occurrences of the same identifier on the given date:
Identifier - A1
Date - 1/1/2018
Bin Column1 Column2 Column3 Column4
1 1 2 3 4
2 1 2 3 4
3
4
5
The Identifier and Date would be manual entries and the rest of the table would be automatically populated. I've been looking up different ways of using index(match()) all morning and have yet to achieve any success. I'm not sure if I'm approaching this incorrectly or what, but any help with this problem is greatly appreciated.
PS - I understand that a pivot table would likely give me the information I need, however, this table isn't for my own use, so I'm trying to make it as straightforward as possible (enter two lines, necessary info pops up).
Edit - This is how the data is currently set up:
`

Answer 1

Use this:
=IFERROR(INDEX(C:C,AGGREGATE(15,7,ROW($B$2:INDEX($B:$B,MATCH("zzz",$A:$A)))/(($B$2:INDEX($B:$B,MATCH("zzz",$A:$A))=$J$2)*($A$2:INDEX($A:$A,MATCH("zzz",$A:$A))=$J$1)),ROW(1:1))),"")
Note: realize this is an array formula that is entered normally with Enter, but as an array formula it will slow down the calcs if the dataset is large.

Answer 2

It generally looks like:
=INDEX('range all of the data, not the headers', MATCH('row header value to match','the row headers range',0), MATCH('column header to match','the column headers range',0))