python client recv only reciving on exit inside BGE - python-3.x

Question

using python 3, I'm trying to send a file from a server to a client as soon as the client connects to the server, problem is that the client do only continue from recv when I close it (when the connection is closed)
I'm running the client in blender game engine, the client is running until it gets to recv, then it just stops, until i exit the game engine, then I can see that the console is receiving the bytes expected.
from other threads I have read that this might be bco the recv never gets an end, that's why I added "\n\r" to the end of my bytearray that the server is sending. but still, the client just stops at recv until I exit the application.
in the code below I'm only sending the first 6 bytes, these are to tell the client the size of the file. after this i intend to send data of the file on the same connection.
what am I doing wrong here?
client:
import socket
import threading
def TcpConnection():
TCPsocket = socket.socket(socket.AF_INET, socket.SOCK_STREAM)
TCPsocket.setsockopt(socket.IPPROTO_TCP, socket.TCP_NODELAY, 1)
server_address = ('localhost', 1338)
TCPsocket.connect(server_address)
print("TCP Socket open!, starting thread!")
ServerResponse = threading.Thread(target=TcpReciveMessageThread,args=(TCPsocket,))
ServerResponse.daemon = True
ServerResponse.start()
def TcpReciveMessageThread(Sock):
print("Tcp thread running!")
size = Sock.recv(6)#Sock.MSG_WAITALL
print("Recived data", size)
Sock.close()
Server:
import threading
import socket
import os
def StartTcpSocket():
server_socket = socket.socket(socket.AF_INET, socket.SOCK_STREAM)
server_socket.bind(('localhost', 1338))
server_socket.listen(10)
while 1:
connection, client_address = server_socket.accept()
Response = threading.Thread(target=StartTcpClientThread,args=(connection,))
Response.daemon = True # thread dies when main thread (only non-daemon thread) exits.
Response.start()
def StartTcpClientThread(socket):
print("Sending data")
length = 42
l1 = ToByts(length)
socket.send(l1)
#loop that sends the file goes here
print("Data sent")
#socket.close()
def ToByts(Size):
byt_res = (Size).to_bytes(4,byteorder='big')
result = bytearray()
for r in byt_res:
result.append(r)
t = bytearray("\r\n","utf-8")
for b in t:
result.append(b)
return result
MessageListener = threading.Thread(target=StartTcpSocket)
MessageListener.daemon = True # thread dies when main thread (only non-daemon thread) exits.
MessageListener.start()
while 1:
pass
if the problem is that the client don't find a end of the stream, then how can solve this without closing the connection, as I intend to send the file on the same connection.
Update #1:
to clarify, the print in the client that say "recived" is printed first when I exit the ge (the client is closing). The loop that sends the file and recives it where left out of the question as they are not the problem. the problem still occurs without them, client freeze at recv until it is closed.
Update #2:
here are a image of what my consoles are printing when i run the server and client:
as you can see it is never printing the "Recived" print
when i exit the blender game engine, I get this output:
now, when the engine and the server script is exited/closed/finished i get the data printed. so recv is probably pausing the thread until the socket is closed, why are it doing this? and how can i get my data (and the print) before the socket is closing? This also happens if I set
ServerResponse.daemon = False
here are a .blend (on mediafire) of the client, the server running on python 3 (pypy). I'm using blender 2.78a
Update #3:
I tested and verified that the problem is the same on windows 10 and linux mint. I also made a Video showing the problem:
In the video you can see how I only receive data from the server when i exit blender ge. After some research I besinning to suspect that the problem is related to python threading not playing well with the bge.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T5l9YGIoDYA

Answer 1

I have observed a similar phenomenon. It appears that the Python instance doesn't receive any execution cycles from Blender Game Engine (BGE) unless a controller gets invoked.
A simple solution is:
Add another Always sensor that is fired on every logic tick.
Add another Python controller that does nothing, a no-op.
Hook the sensor to the controller.
I applied this to your .blend as shown in the following screen capture.
I tested it by running your server and it seems to work OK.
Cheers, Jim