Is there anyway to write dlls in linux?
Do I have to install windows to write dlls in linux? Right now one of my courses requires me to write a dll for this.
You should take a look into 'shared libraries'
http://www.linux.org/docs/ldp/howto/Program-Library-HOWTO/shared-libraries.html
Lots of folks are getting near the right answer but not providing it: gcc can generate win32 PE/COFF files without problem, and of course can always build as a cross compiler on any platform it can target. The binutils port targets windows .exe and .dll files natively, and there's a "dlltool" utility for handling the edge cases where Unix and Windows linkage metaphors are different.
Additionally, the "mingw32" project provides a set of link libraries and header files for building C applications against the win32 API. These likewise install just fine on any Unix.
Here's a site I turned up after a quick google with instructions for building the toolchain.
Not really. Building any kind of executable intended for OS "A" while using OS "B" is a process commonly known as cross-compilation. In this partciluar case, you would need a cross-compiler running on Linux, but targetting Windows. I don't know any vendor selling such a product.
Related
I'm working on a project, which targets both Windows and Linux (and possible in the future MacOS). It consists of some applications with several shared libraries. It is written in modern C++ and modern CMake. It also uses 3rd-party libraries like Qt, OpenCV, Boost, GraphicsMagick, samplerate, sndfile. Those dependencies are handled through Conan package manager. I'm building both on Linux (Ubuntu 18.04, GCC 8.1) and Windows (via WSL - also Ubuntu 18.04, MinGW-w64 8.1). I'm using fairly recent versions of 3rd-party libraries with custom built options (strictly speaking - different versions than available on Ubuntu's APT, e.g. Qt v5.11.3, or custom built of GraphicsMagick)
I'm using CPack. On Windows I'm building NSIS installer, but on Linux I would like to use DEB generator (may be other if needed). All of my targets (written apps and shared libs) have appropriate CMake's INSTALL configurations, so they are copied correctly into the generated installers (component based installation). The real problem comes with packaging of 3rd-party dependencies.
Problem
Strictly speaking, I have no idea, how to do it well using CMake+CPack+Conan, both on Linux and Windows. I've read a lot of articles and posts, but I'm stucked. I would like to have something, that automatically bundles into the installer all 3rd party libraries used by project with needed plugins and, what is the most important, with needed system/compiler libraries (libgomp, libstdc++ and so on).
Possible solution
To my surprise, on Windows, this task is fairly easy, because every DLL used by app (my libs, 3rd-party libs and system/compiler libs) needs to be located where executable is. I'm engaging Conan into this, by importing all used DLLs into bin directory. In the end, in most naive way of packaging, I will just copy the bin directory into the installer and it should work. But I'm not sure, if this approach is OK.
On Linux, things are more complicated. First, there is arleady a package manager. Unfortunately, libraries/compilers available there are too old for me (e.g. on APT there is only Qt 5.9.6 ) and are built using different compile options. So, the only way for me is to ship them with my software (like in Windows). There are also issues with searching for dynamic libraries by ld, RPATH handling and so on. At the moment, the only solution I see is to write something like 'launcher' for my app, which sets LD_LIBRARY_PATH before program starts. After that, in this case we can just copy bin or lib directory to the DEB installer and this should work. But still, I don't know if this is correct approach.
Other solutions
I've also looked into other solutions. One of them was BundleUtilities from CMake. It doesn't work for me. It has a lot of problems in recognizing, whether some library is system or local one. Especially in WSL, where it stucked in processing dependencies to USER32.dll, KERNEL32.dll. BundleUtilities in Windows worked for me only with MSYS, but in MSYS I've failed to compile some 3rd-party libraries (GraphicsMagicks via Conan) and that's the reason, why I'm using WSL.
Summary
I'm looking for good and verified method of packaging C++ projects with multiple apps, libs and shipped 3rd-party libs, both for Windows and Linux. How are you doing things like this? Are you just copying bin and/or lib dirs to the installers? How (in terms of CMake/CPack code) are you doing that? INSTALL(DIRECTORY ...), or similar? I'm not sure, but I think that this problem should be already solved in the industry. ;)
Thanks for all suggestions.
First, Conan is a package manager for development, not for distribution, that's why you didn't find an easy way to solve your problem. Second, most of discussions are made at Conan issue, including bugs and questions. There you will find a big community + Conan devs which are very helpful.
with needed system/compiler libraries
This is not part of Conan. Why you don't use static linkage for system libraries?
Talking about CPack, we have an open discussion about it usage with Conan: https://github.com/conan-io/conan/issues/5655
Please, join us.
I see few options for your case:
on package method, run self.copy and all dependencies from self.cpp_deps, which includes all libraries, so you can run Cpack
Use Conan deploy generator to deploy all artifacts, and using a hook you can run cpack or any other installer tool
Out friend SSE4 is writing a new blog post about Deployment + Conan, I think it can help you a lot. You can read a preview here.
Regards!
Libraries built with Mingw-w64 require those dll:
libwinpthread-1.dll
libstdc++-6.dll
libgcc_s_seh-1.dll
I wonder what's up with that, what each dll does? Especially libgcc_s_seh, is that structured exception handling? I thought mingw couldn't work with seh.
Why mingw requires to always bring those dll with your exe?
I wonder if I'm just wasting my time by not just using visual studio as a windows compiler. It's so bloated though, 9 gb for installation.
Especially libgcc_s_seh, is that structured exception handling? I thought mingw couldn't work with seh.
Newer versions of GCC (4.8+ if I'm correct) should support SEH on MinGW.
I wonder what's up with that, what each dll does?
They provide the runtime and standard library.
libwinpthread: PThreads implementation on Windows (Threading)
libstdc++: C++ Standard Library (C/C++ library functions etc.)
libgcc_s_seh: Exception handling (SEH)
Why mingw requires to always bring those dll with your exe?
Because your program uses them. If you write a program without threads, standard library and exception and any OS interaction you wont need them.
These DLL's bring everything you need to run your program. Btw. this is not a MinGW only thing, and happens on other systems / compilers too. Often you just don't note this because the OS already ships the libraries, eg. MSVC libraries are very likely on a Windows machine. Dynamic linking always requires some sort of library files, that are .dll on Windows and .so on Linux.
If you have it available on your system use ldd <your application> to see what libraries are dynamically linked.
You can install these MinGW libraries into the system libraries or somewhere where the OS can find it. This enables your programs to use it and you no longer have to ship it with every application (what avoids duplication).
On the other side another option is to static link them. Unlike dynamic linking, you don't need any DLL; on the downside is a increase of you applications size (as now the three libraries are baked into the exe now).
I wonder if I'm just wasting my time by not just using visual studio as a windows compiler.
This depends on your situation. But probably my answer will give you some more insight.
I have source code for a linux application. It seems I can compile it on windows with CygWin. My question is, after compilation, can I run it on Windows?
Depends totally on what APIs you use. If you stick to C standard library things, like <stdio.h>, <stdlib.h>, etc. then yes, you can just compile and run on either OS. Or for C++ apps, there is the Standard C++ Library, which any OS / development environment should provide.
If you use any OS-specific APIs, then of course it will not be compatible with another OS. There are libraries however, like APR that try to abstract out the OS-specific bits.
From a casual glance at the code you've linked to, it appears to not use any OS-specific APIs. However:
Note that this code requires the Gnu Scientific Library, http://www.gnu.org/software/gsl/
you'll need to get that library installed as well.
The simple answer is yes; if you can compile a Linux application with Cygwin, then the compiled application will run on windows. Cygwin provides windows implementations of many unix system functions and libraries.
Cygwin/mingw(http://www.mingw.org/) should have most of the tools you need to build the binary. Once the build succeeds, you can run the binary (only) on windows.
As per my knowledge, windows uses .lib and .dll extension for libraries and linux uses .a and .so. I am working on a project in ubuntu for manipulation with jpeg image files. so i want to know if these libraries can be used interchangeably in linux and windows? for example if have created example.so library in ubuntu and now i want to use it in some compiler in windows...
If you're planning on running under Wine, then yes.
Otherwise the chances are small. Windows DLLs will most probably use Windows APIs not available on Linux. Even if they're not the DLLs are built for use with compilers running on Windows.
Why not use imagemagick? http://www.imagemagick.org/script/index.php
I have a little application running on Linux and want to port it to Windows. I found that with Cygwin i will be able to do it simple by linking the application with the cygwin1.dll library which make available a lot of the POSIX and other standard functions. I read the FAQ and the User Guide on the site of Cygwin but didn't find or didn't understand how can I link my source with this library.
My application uses GTK+ and I successfully compiled and link it on Windows with MinGW but I have to disable some of the functionality .Now that I find Cygwin I would like to link with it to make available again this functionality.
Generally you compile your source inside of Cygwin to produce the Windows binary. I'm pretty sure Cygwin will take care of linking to the proper dlls for you.
When you finally get the binary compiled, make sure that the cygwin1.dll is in the PATH specified by Windows.