I'm really just looking for some kind of tool that will check for close approximations of duplicates in a column of data. For instance, say I have a column of data with addresses as such:
113 James Way
3448 Harlon Circle
5888 Murray Rd
3448 Harlon Cr.
In this case entry 2 and 4 would be very close to unique and I would like some kind of tool, either in excel or standalone, that would notify me if rows are being duplicated or approximately duplicated. I have no idea how to even search for something like this. I tried searches for fuzzy match tools and the like but nothing is quite what I need. Thanks,
There are several ways to approach
One simple method is to write a Levenshtein function to compare these addressed with each other and highlight low values
Assume you have the data setup as follows
Raw example
Sub FindClosestMatch()
Range("B3").Select
Dim mystrings()
Range("B3").Select
Range(Selection, Selection.End(xlDown)).Select
mystrings = Selection.Value
i = 0
Dim string1 As String, string2 As String
Range("C3").Select
For i = LBound(mystrings) To UBound(mystrings)
string1 = mystrings(i, 1)
For j = 1 To 4
string2 = mystrings(j, 1)
ActiveCell.Value = Levenshtein(string1, string2)
ActiveCell.Offset(0, 1).Select
Next
Range("c3").Offset(i, 0).Select
Next
End Sub
How to read values
For e.g 113 James Way 0 15 13 12 means the string has a score of
0 (exact match) with itself
15 with 3448 Harlon Circle
13 With 5888 Murray Rd
12 with 3448 Harlon Cr.
etc
The Macro just compares every address with other address and finds the Levenshtein distance
The lower the number the closest match they are and clearly 0 is exact match when it compares to itself
This macro assumes you have copied the Levenshtein function into your VBA Module
It really depends on how accurate you need it to be and what kind of close matches you want it to catch. If you want to catch typos it'd be a lot harder. But if you're mainly looking to catch St vs Street you could do a vlookup on the left(address, #) or something. Might have to toy with the # to get a good response. # needs to be higher then the number of digits in the street numbers (4/5?) but small enough to catch things like 1 dry ct. I'd guess 7-8.
Basically your addresses are in column A (assuming starting in A2 with headers). Column B says = left(a2,8)
A2 is obviously unique cause it's first.
Start in C3 with =vlookup(left(a3,8),$B$2:B2,1,0)
It'll print an error for all the unique entries and an address for the dupilcates. To make it cleaner you can add an if(iserror()) with
=if(iserror(vlookup(left(a3,8),$B$2:B2,1,0), "", vlookup(left(a3,8),$B$2:B2,1,0))
Related
I have this string of text, it could be larger, this is an example:
2.01g 10k gold wedding band~15xps3 games~14.01 14k diamond solitaire with .30pt diamond~2ps3 games~14dvds
Every time it sees the "~", for example, I want it to paste values in cell g34. If there is more than one row, I want it to continue pasting the values into g35, g36, g37 and so on until the list is exhausted.
I want this to be done in VBA so I can attach it to a button. I do not want to do it by text to columns.
The result should look like this:
2.01g 10k gold wedding band
15xps3 games
14.01 14k diamond solitaire with .30pt diamond
2ps3 games
14dvds
Any help GREATLY appreciated...I can find similar solutions, but most want to paste it into new columns.
Consider:
Sub parse()
Dim s As String
s = "2.01g 10k gold wedding band~15xps3 games~14.01 14k diamond solitaire with .30pt diamond~2ps3 games~14dvds"
arr = Split(s, "~")
Range("G34").Resize(UBound(arr) + 1, 1) = Application.Transpose(arr)
End Sub
Please take a look at the attached image. I have a long list of items and I've created a common keywords to search in that list. I'm using this formula:
=INDEX(A:A,MATCH((("*"&B2&"*")&("*"&C2&"*")&("*"&D2&"*")&("*"&E2&"*")&("*"&F2&"*")),A:A,0))
The problem that the search is going through the same sequence that I entered.
It gives error if the sequence of the words in the cell is different than the sequence in my formula which make sense.
Is there a way I can search for 3 or more words that are existing in any cell in any sequence?
I am open to using VBA if necessary.
My search results:
Here is the user defined function:
Public Function indexMX(rng As Range, pat1 As Range, pat2 As Range, pat3 As Range, pat4 As Range, pat5 As Range) As Variant
Dim r As Range, rngx As Range, s(1 To 5) As String, Kount As Long, j As Long
s(1) = pat1.Value
s(2) = pat2.Value
s(3) = pat3.Value
s(4) = pat4.Value
s(5) = pat5.Value
Set rngx = Intersect(rng, rng.Parent.UsedRange)
For Each r In rngx
v = r.Value
Kount = 0
For j = 1 To 5
If InStr(1, v, s(j)) > 0 Or s(j) = "" Then Kount = Kount + 1
Next j
If Kount = 5 Then
indexMX = v
Exit Function
End If
Next r
indexMX = "no luck"
End Function
Here is an example of its usage:
As you see, we give the UDF() the address of the column and the addresses of the five keywords and the UDF() finds the first item containing all five words.
If a keyword is blank, it is not used. (so if you want to search for only two keywords, leave the other three blank). If no matches are found the phrase no luck is returned.
User Defined Functions (UDFs) are very easy to install and use:
ALT-F11 brings up the VBE window
ALT-I
ALT-M opens a fresh module
paste the stuff in and close the VBE window
If you save the workbook, the UDF will be saved with it.
If you are using a version of Excel later then 2003, you must save
the file as .xlsm rather than .xlsx
To remove the UDF:
bring up the VBE window as above
clear the code out
close the VBE window
To use the UDF from Excel:
=myfunction(A1)
To learn more about macros in general, see:
http://www.mvps.org/dmcritchie/excel/getstarted.htm
and
http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ee814735(v=office.14).aspx
and for specifics on UDFs, see:
http://www.cpearson.com/excel/WritingFunctionsInVBA.aspx
Macros must be enabled for this to work!
EDIT#1:
to remove case sensitivity, replace:
If InStr(1, v, s(j)) > 0 Or s(j) = "" Then Kount = Kount + 1
with:
If InStr(1, LCase(v), LCase(s(j))) > 0 Or s(j) = "" Then Kount = Kount + 1
Yes, it is possible for a single cell to return three matching words from a different cell. The answer in this example uses a formula to return 6 matches. VBA and special array functions are not used.
This is the formula:
=SUBSTITUTE(SUBSTITUTE(SUBSTITUTE(SUBSTITUTE(SUBSTITUTE(SUBSTITUTE(SUBSTITUTE(SUMPRODUCT((IFERROR(SEARCH(FIRST,TARGET),0)>0)*100000+(IFERROR(SEARCH(SECOND,TARGET),0)>0)*20000+(IFERROR(SEARCH(THIRD,TARGET),0)>0)*3000+(IFERROR(SEARCH(FOURTH,TARGET),0)>0)*400+(IFERROR(SEARCH(FIFTH,TARGET),0)>0)*50+(IFERROR(SEARCH(SIXTH,TARGET),0)>0)*6),"1",FIRST&DELIM),"2",SECOND&DELIM),"3",THIRD&DELIM),"4",FOURTH&DELIM),"5",FIFTH&DELIM),"6",SIXTH&DELIM),"0","")
Did you notice the named ranges? FIRST, SECOND, THIRD, etc are individual cells and each one holds a word. We are trying to find those words inside TARGET. If we find the words, then we will write them in this cell holding this formula and each word will be separated by DELIM
The ranges are optional. In the picture below, you'll see cell A2 contains the word "named". This is the first of the six words we're tying to find and it can be expressed as FIRST = "A2" = "named" Inside the formula you'll see that FIRST appears twice. You could replace it with "named" and the cell A2 would become blank but the functionality of the formula would not change.
Even TARGET is optional. It could be written as E1 or typed out word for word.
I don't know why anyone would do that... but it is possible.
DELIM is at cell B2, it is a double space
Now to explain how it works
SEARCH(search for what?, search where?) This is responsible for determining if a match exists or not. If you understand what the named ranges then you've already figured out the syntax is. The location of first letter that of match in TARGET is returned. In this formula it is always 1 If it is not found then the number is 0
IFERROR(value,value) tries to perform the operation. If successful then the result is displayed. If there's an error the second result is displayed. Every IFERROR in this formula is practically the same: IFERROR(SEARCH(FIRST,TARGET),0) It searches inside TARGET trying to find the FIRST word. Result if found is 1 and if not found is 0
It gets a little more complicated from here so lets recap. We're calling SEARCH 6 times. Once for each word we want to find and we're always looking in TARGET. Result will be a 1 if match is found or a 0 if not. Ironically, us humans can put it together and see the match but the formula can't determine which words have been matched without more information
SUMPRODUCT takes the sum (addition) of the product (multiplication) of two or more arrays.
multiply two arrays to get the product
a, b, c * e, f, g = ae, bf, cg
takethe sum of the product to get the SUMPRODUCT
ae + bf + cg`
This is easiest when thought of a price and quantity. If one array is the price of a group of items and the other is quantity of the same group of items, then multiplying the two arrays will create a new array where each element is the cost to buy all items of that type in the group the total, and adding all those numbers give you the total cost you'd pay for all of the items
Here we multiply two arrays:
Qty Price
12.0 0.3
70.0 0.1
20.0 0.4
Multiply them to get the product:
Qty Price Total
12.0 0.3 3.8
70.0 0.1 7.0
20.0 0.4 8.0
Take the sum of the product:
Qty Price Total
12.0 0.3 3.8
70.0 0.1 7.0
20.0 0.4 8.0
18.8 SUMPRODUCT
Lets look at part of the formula:
SUMPRODUCT((IFERROR(SEARCH(FIRST,TARGET),0)>0)*100000+IFERROR(SEARCH(SECOND,TARGET),0)>0)*20000+...
It is easy to see this segment is looking for two words. We know SUMPRODUCT want's to multiply and add arrays. If you're thinking (IFERROR(SEARCH(FIRST,TARGET),0)>0) is an array, you'd be right! It's not an array in the technical sense of the word, but it does evaluate into a single value which can thought of as a 1x1 array, or, a cell. The sharp eyed and quick witted, may have noticed there is something on this array we have mentioned. It's the inequality at the end! Many of you know that you can take numerical values and turn them into boolean by testing them with an inequality. So lets evaluate.... SEARCH for FIRST inside TARGET = 1 because FIRST = "named" which is inside TARGET waaaaaaay in the back and because it wasn't an error we get to keep the 1. Next we do the inequality 1 > 0 = TRUE One is greater than zero and evaluates to TRUE
This is what we have right now
SUMPRODUCT((TRUE*100000+IFERROR(SEARCH(SECOND,TARGET),0)>0)*20000+....
Can you identify the arrays now? We know TRUE is an array, a 1x1. You know the IFERROR bit all the way to the inequality is also an array. Lets evaluate that IFERROR .... Mathematically we should still be working from left to right but trust me, we're ok if we let it slide this once.
IFERROR(SEARCH(SECOND,TARGET),0)>0) SECOND = "array" = 1 = TRUE
Did you follow my short hand? It's ok if you didn't just back up and practice on FIRST until you understand.
Plugging in the value gives us something like this
SUMPRODUCT(TRUE*100000+TRUE*20000+...
SUMPRODUCT is the SUM(addition) of the PRODUCT(multiplication)
So we're adding the stuff we multiply
SUMPRODUCT = (TRUE * 100000) + (TRUE * 20000)
Remember how easy it was to go from 1 > 0 to TRUE. We're "getting all up into that boolean TRUE that" equals 1 Here's a fun fact, -1 is also equal to TRUE. If you've ever seen a formula with a double negative in it like this STUFF(--(MORESTUFF( that's just some Excel wizard person making sure they get a +1 instead of a -1 ... ok, so lets get back on track and evalute
SUMPRODCUT = 1 * 100000 + 1 * 20000+....
SUMPRODCUT = 100000 + 20000+....
SUMPRODCUT = 120000+.....
I know you've been asking about those numbers. One hundred thousand? What's one hundred thousand for? I've been purposefully ignoring until it became convenient to talk about it. And now it's convenient. Go look at the whoooole formula and you'll find a pattern. Those numbers are in a decreasing sequence. Anyone who's ever done bitwise logic can see where this is going.I'm running short on time so I'll cut to the chase. Assume a hypothetical situation where every word was matched. You'd end up with
SUMPRODUCT = 100000 + 20000 + 3000 + 400 + 50 + 6
SUMPRODCUT = 123456
123456 are you pulling my leg? No, I am not. We're almost done so if you're still with me then you're gonna drive it home.
We have a large group of SUBSTITUTE teachers at the front of the line and we gotta get rid of them.
We also have this to contend with :"1",FIRST&DELIM),"2",SECOND&DELIM),"3",THIRD&DELIM),"4",FOURTH&DELIM),"5",FIFTH&DELIM),"6",SIXTH&DELIM),"0","")
Thankfully for us, they are part of the same problem. We worked our way from the middle out.
SUBSTITUTE(SUBSTITUTE(text, old text, new text)
SUBSTITUTE(SUBSTITUTE("123456","1", FIRST & DELIM),"2",SECOND & DELIM)....
Remember at top DELIM was pointing to a cell holding a double space. Each DELIM can be replaced with " " or any other delimiter you want.
SUBSTITUTE(SUBSTITUTE("123456","1", "named" & " "),"2",SECOND & DELIM)...
SUBSTITUTE("named 23456","2",SECOND & DELIM)...
SUBSTITUTE("named 23456","2","array"& " ")...
("named array 3456")... and so on.
Any questions?
Ok, class is dismissed!
Say I have columns
/670 - White | /650 - black | /680 - Red | /800 - Whitest
These have data in their rows. Basically, I want to SUM their values together if their headers contain my desired string.
For modularity's sake, I wanted to merely specify to sum /670, /650, and /680 without having to mention the rest of the header text.
So, something like =SUMIF(a1:c1; "/NUM & /NUM & /NUM"; a2:c2)
That doesn't work, and honestly I don't know what i should be looking for.
Additional stuff:
I'm trying to think of the answer myself, is it possible to mention the header text as condition for ifs? Like: if A2="/650 - Black" then proceed to sum the next header. Is this possible?
Possibility it would not involve VBA, a draggable formula would be preferable!
At this point, I may as well request a version which handles the complete header name rather than just a part of it as I believe it to be difficult for formula code alone.
Thanks for having a look!
Let me know if I need to elaborate.
EDIT: In regards to data samples, any positive number will do actually, damn shame stack overflow doesn't support table markdown. Anyway, for example then..:
+-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+
| A | B | C | D | E |
+---+-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+
| 1 |/650 - Black |/670 - White |/800 - White |/680 - Red |/650 - Black |
+---+-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+
| 2 | 250 | 400 | 100 | 300 | 125 |
+---+-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+
I should have clarified:
The number range for these headers would go from /100 - /9999 and no more than that.
EDIT:
Progress so far:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1GiJKFcPWzG5bDsNt93eG7WS_M5uuVk9cvkt2VGSbpxY/edit?usp=sharing
Formula:
=SUMPRODUCT((A2:D2*
(MID($A$1:$D$1,2,4)=IF(LEN($H$1)=4,$H$1&"",$H$1&" ")))+(A2:D2*
(MID($A$1:$D$1,2,4)=IF(LEN($I$1)=4,$I$1&"",$I$1&" ")))+(A2:D2*
(MID($A$1:$D$1,2,4)=IF(LEN($J$1)=4,$J$1&"",$J$1&" "))))
Apparently, each MID function is returning false with each F9 calculation.
EDIT EDIT:
Okay! I found my issue, it's the /being read when you ALSO mentioned that it wasn't required. Man, I should stop skimming!
Final Edit:
=SUMPRODUCT((RETURNSUM*
(MID(HEADER,2,4)=IF(LEN(Match5)=4,Match5&"",Match5&" ")))+(RETURNSUM*
(MID(HEADER,2,4)=IF(LEN(Match6)=4,Match6&"",Match6&" ")))+(RETURNSUM*
(MID(HEADER,2,4)=IF(LEN(Match7)=4,Match7&"",Match7&" ")))
The idea is that Header and RETURNSUM will become match criteria like the matches written above, that way it would be easier to punch new criterion into the search table. As of the moment, it doesn't support multiple rows/dragging.
I have knocked up a couple of formulas that will achieve what you are looking for. For ease I have made the search input require the number only as pressing / does not automatically type into the formula bar. I apologise for the length of the answer, I got a little carried away with the explanation.
I have set this up for 3 criteria located in J1, K1 and L1.
Here is the output I achieved:
Formula 1 - SUMPRODUCT():
=SUMPRODUCT((A4:G4*(MID($A$1:$G$1,2,4)=IF(LEN($J$1)=4,$J$1&"",$J$1&" ")))+(A4:G4*(MID($A$1:$G$1,2,4)=IF(LEN($K$1)=4,$K$1&"",$K$1&" ")))+(A4:G4*(MID($A$1:$G$1,2,4)=IF(LEN($L$1)=4,$L$1&"",$L$1&" "))))
Sumproduct(array1,[array2]) behaves as an array formula without needed to be entered as one. Array formulas break down ranges and calculate them cell by cell (in this example we are using single rows so the formula will assess columns seperately).
(A4:G4*(MID($A$1:$G$1,2,4)=IF(LEN($J$1)=4,$J$1&"",$J$1&" ")))
Essentially I have broken the Sumproduct() formula into 3 identical parts - 1 for each search condition. (A4:G4*: Now, as the formula behaves like an array, we will multiply each individual cell by either 1 or 0 and add the results together.
1 is produced when the next part of the formula is true and 0 for when it is false (default numeric values for TRUE/FALSE).
(MID($A$1:$G$1,2,4)=IF(LEN($J$1)=4,$J$1&"",$J$1&" "))
MID(text,start_num,num_chars) is being used here to assess the 4 digits after the "/" and see whether they match with the number in the 3 cells that we are searching from (in this case the first one: J1). Again, as SUMPRODUCT() works very much like an array formula, each cell in the range will be assessed individually.
I have then used the IF(logical_test,[value_if_true],[value_if_false]) to check the length of the number that I am searching. As we are searching for a 4 digit text string, if the number is 4 digits then add nothing ("") to force it to a text string and if it is not (as it will have to be 3 digits) add 1 space to the end (" ") again forcing it to become a text string.
The formula will then perform the calculation like so:
The MID() formula produces the array: {"650 ","670 ","800 ","680 ","977 ","9999","143 "}. This combined with the first search produces {TRUE,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE} which when multiplied by A4:G4
(remember 0 for false and 1 for true) produces this array: {250,0,0,0,0,0,0} essentially pulling the desired result ready to be summed together.
Formula 2: =SUM(IF(Array)): [This formula does not work for 3 digit numbers as they will exist within the 4 digit numbers! I have included it for educational purposes only]
=SUM(IF(ISNUMBER(SEARCH($J$1,$A$1:$G$1)),A8:G8),IF(ISNUMBER(SEARCH($K$1,$A$1:$G$1)),A8:G8),IF(ISNUMBER(SEARCH($L$1,$A$1:$G$1)),A8:G8))
The formula will need to be entered as an array (once copy and pasted while still in the formula bar hit CTRL+SHIFT+ENTER)
This formula works in a similar way, SUM() will add together the array values produced where IF(ISNUMBER(SEARCH() columns match the result column.
SEARCH() will return a number when it finds the exact characters in a cell which represents it's position in number of characters. By using ISNUMBER() I am avoiding having to do the whole MID() and IF(LEN()=4,""," ") I used in the previous formula as TRUE/FALSE will be produced when a match is found regardless of it's position or cell formatting.
As previously mentioned, this poses a problem as 999 can be found within 9999 etc.
The resulting array for the first part is: {250,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE} (if you would like to see the array you can highlight that part of the formula and calculate with F9 but be sure to highlight the exact brackets for that part of the formula).
I hope I have explained this well, feel free to ask any questions about stuff that you don't understand. It is good to see people keen to learn and not just fishing for a fast answer. I would be more than happy to help and explain in more depth.
I start this solution with the names in an array, you can read the header names into an array with not too much difficulty.
Sub test()
Dim myArray(1 To 4) As String
myArray(1) = "/670 - White"
myArray(2) = "/650 - black"
myArray(3) = "/680 - Red"
myArray(4) = "/800 - Whitest"
For Each ArrayValue In myArray
'Find position of last character
endposition = InStr(1, ArrayValue, " - ", vbTextCompare)
'Grab the number section from the string, based on starting and ending positions
stringvalue = Mid(ArrayValue, 2, endposition - 2)
'Convert to number
NumberValue = CLng(stringvalue)
'Add to total
Total = Total + NumberValue
Next ArrayValue
'Print total
Debug.Print Total
End Sub
This will print the answer to the debug window.
I want you to have some fun. I need something specific.
First i must explain what i do. I use a simple codification for product prices at retail store, because i dont want people know the real price for themselves. So i change the original numbers to another subtracting the number 9 for each number.
Normally I manually write down all the prices with this codification for every product.
So.. for example number 10 would be 89. (9-1 = 8) and (9-0 = 9)
Other examples:
$128 = 871
$75 = 24
$236 = 763
$9 = 0
Finally i put 2 number nines (9) at the beginning of the codified price also, to confuse people who might think that number could be the price.
So the examples i used before are like this:
99871 (means $128)
9924 (means $75)
99763 (means $236)
990 (means $9)
Remember that i need 2 (two) nines before the real price. The real prices never start with 0 so, the nines at the beginning exist only to confuse people.
Ok. So, now that you understand, here comes the 2nd part.
I have an excel whith hundreds of my products added, with prices, description, etc. And i decided it is time to use a printer and start to print this information from excel. I have a software to do that, but first i need to have the codified prices in the excel also.
The fun part begins when i want to convert the real prices that are already written in my excel document into a new column AUTOMATICALLY. So that way i don´t have to type again all the prices in codified form for the old and new items i add in the future.
Can someone help me with this? Is it even possible?
I tried with =A1-9999 but, it works well with 2 character number only. Because if the real price is 5, i will get 3 nines: 9994(code). And if the price is 234 i will get only 1 nine 9765(code). And it is a condition i need to have the TWO nines at first.
Thank you very much in advanced!
Though you have requested for formula , I am suggesting VBA program which seems to me very convenient.
You have to open VBE and insert a module and copy the program. Change the code lines wherever indicated to suit your requirements for sheets etc.
Sub NumberCode()
Dim c As Range
Dim LR As Integer
Dim numProbs As Long
Dim sht As Worksheet
Dim s As Integer
Dim v As Long
Dim v1 As Long
Set sht = Worksheets("Sheet1") ' change as per yr requirement
numProbs = 0
LR = sht.Cells(Rows.Count, "A").End(xlUp).Row
For Each c In sht.Range("A1:A" & LR).Cells
s = Len(c)
v = c.Value
v1 = 99
For s = 1 To Len(c)
v1 = v1 & (9 - Mid(c, s, 1))
Next
c.Offset(0, 1).Value = v1
v1 = 99
numProbs = numProbs + 1
Next
MsgBox "Number coding finished"
End Sub
Sample sheet of results is appended below.
I will be using helper cells but you could dump it all into one cell if you want since you are only dealing with 4 characters.
For the purpose of this example, I am assuming your original price list starts in B11.
=IFERROR(9-MID($B11,COLUMN(A1),1),"")
Place that in D11 and copy to the right three more times so you have it from D11 to G11. That formula strips off 1 character from your price and subtracts that character from 9. When you go the next column it repeats itself. If you do not have that many characters, it will return "".
In C11 you will build your number based on the adjacent 4 columns using this formula:
="99"&D11&E11&F11&G11
It places 99 in front then adds the numbers from the adjacent 4 columns.
Select cells C11 to G11 and copy and paste downward beside your data column as far as you need to go.
An alternate more concise method would be:
=REPT(9,LEN(B11)+2)-B11
Perhaps I'm missing something, though simply:
=REPT(9,2+LEN(A1))-A1
seems good to me.
Regards
Working in Microsoft Excel, I have a spreadsheet with the equivalent of a shopping list, if the Quantity is greater than 0 then I wish to display the description on another sheet.
This is something that is quite simple using the INDEX function, however this only returns the first value that matches.
How should I re-factor the query below, to return the value of (n)
=INDEX(Software!B23:Software!B34,MATCH(TRUE,INDEX(Software!A23:Software!A34<>0,0),0))
Having assumed this to be an array, I mistaking thought I could call Array[n] for the location, however this has proven incorrect.
Thank you for your assistance.
In this case, you don't want to use MATCH(), you want to use the SMALL() and IF() functions together...
=INDEX(Software!$B$23:$B$34,SMALL(IF(Software!$A$23:$A$34>0,ROW(Software!$A$23:$A$34)),ROW(A1))-ROW(Software!$B$23)+1)
Entered as an array formula
Basically, what you're saying is:
Give me the row for which the data in Column A > 0 for the Kth smallest time
Now take that row and subtract from it the starting row of my dataset and give me back that entry from the array I have in column A.
And you could wrap the whole thing in an IFERROR() statement too to not have error values pop up.
One place to find more data about this would be here
Hope that makes sense and does the trick!
This might be useful (dont know exactly this is what u want)
Sub test_index()
Dim ii As Integer, jj As Integer
ii = 23
jj = 24
With ActiveSheet
For ii = 23 To 34
Cells(ii, 12).Formula = "=INDEX(Software!B" & ii & ":Software!B" & ii & _
",MATCH(TRUE,INDEX(Software!A" & ii & ":Software!A" & ii & ",0,0),0))"
Next
End With
End Sub